Zcash Dev Fund Poll - Ecosystem Engineers (June 2024)
public election created by 
Jason McGee
[archived]
Voting start at June 8, 2024, 12:01 a.m.
Voting end at June 14, 2024, 11:59 p.m.
questions (11) | voters & ballots | trustees (1)
This election is complete.
Tally
Question #1Which of the following statements best reflects your opinion?
| The Dev Fund should be renewed after the next halving in late 2024. | 19 |
| The Dev Fund should end, and 100% of the block reward should go to miners. | 1 |
If the Dev Fund is renewed, it:
| Should remain 20% of the block reward | 15 |
| Should be less than 20% of the block reward | 2 |
| Should be more than 20% of the block reward | 3 |
If the Dev Fund is renewed, how long should it last for before having to be renewed again?
| 1 year | 5 |
| 2 years | 10 |
| 3 years | 0 |
| 4 years | 5 |
Which Dev Fund model do you support most?
| A direct funding model where a portion of the block rewards goes directly to organizations (e.g. ECC, ZF, ZCG) similar to the current version of the Dev Fund. | 9 |
| A non-direct funding model like or similar to the Zcash Funding Bloc, where, for example, funds locked in a multi-signature wallet are allocated by trusted community participants through major and minor grants. | 10 |
| An alternative model or option not listed above | 0 |
| The Dev Fund should not be renewed | 1 |
Do you support extending the current Dev Fund for one year to give the community more time to explore and implement a non-direct funding model, like the Zcash Funding Bloc? See link to draft ZIP.
| Yes | 14 |
| No | 6 |
If the current Dev Fund model is renewed, would you support more independent entities (in addition to the existing three) receiving a slice of the Dev Fund even if that means giving less % to the existing recipients?
| Yes | 15 |
| No | 4 |
Overall, how would you rate the Electric Coin Company's performance as a Dev Fund recipient?
| Excellent | 2 |
| Good | 10 |
| Average | 4 |
| Below Average | 4 |
| Poor | 0 |
Overall, how would you rate the Zcash Foundation's performance as a Dev Fund recipient?
| Excellent | 3 |
| Good | 12 |
| Average | 2 |
| Below Average | 2 |
| Poor | 1 |
Overall, how would you rate Zcash Community Grants' performance as a Dev Fund recipient?
| Excellent | 2 |
| Good | 12 |
| Average | 4 |
| Below Average | 1 |
| Poor | 1 |
Zcash Community Grants is a committee under the Zcash Foundation, and not a separate organization. Would you support Zcash Community Grants becoming a fully-independent entity capable of managing its own operations and organizational structure?
| Yes | 12 |
| No | 8 |
The Zcash Trademark Agreement is a bilateral agreement between ECC and ZF that ultimately determines what is called “Zcash”. Among other things, the Agreement requires both entities to sign off on any network upgrade before it can be implemented. In addition, neither party is permitted to take actions that violate “the clear consensus of the Zcash community.” Earlier this year, ECC announced its intention to terminate the Agreement. If ECC unilaterally terminates the Agreement without concession from ZF, then ZF will gain sole ownership of the trademark. Which of the following statements best reflects your opinion on the trademark?
| The Zcash Foundation should maintain unilateral control over the trademark, including governing network upgrades, soliciting community sentiment through ZCAP and other methods. | 5 |
| The trademark should be limited to addressing violations of misuse and abuse only, and should not be used to govern network upgrades. | 11 |
| The Trademark Agreement should be completely invalidated. | 4 |